11964
Shelter Island, New York.
Shelter Island, Suffolk County, NY · New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA metro · population 2,906
to buy the typical home at today's mortgage rate — +$5,800 (+160%) since Jan 2020.
- 1 year
- Up $104,986 +6%
- $1,691,514$1,796,500 since Sep 2025
- 5 years
- Up $517,018 +40%
- $1,279,482$1,796,500 since Sep 2021
Monthly payment to buy the typical home
Home value × that month's 30-year mortgage rate, 20% down, principal and interest. This is the line households feel: prices and rates compound each other.
- 11964$9,429
- United States$1,922
At the last five years' pace, a typical home here doubles in price every 10 years.
Typical home values in zip 11964 rose 6.2% over the past year — faster than the nation's +1.2%.
Zillow also publishes an index for the city itself: Shelter Island, NY — measured over the city limits, which is a different area from this zip.
Typical home value — 11964
Mid-tier homes, smoothed and seasonally adjusted.
- 11964$1,796,500
- New York$730,949
- United States$366,157
Within 20 miles
| Miles sorted ascending, activate to sort descending | Zip activate to sort by Zip | City activate to sort by City | Population activate to sort by Population | Rent activate to sort by Rent | Home value activate to sort by Home value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.0 | 11965 | Shelter Island Heights | 404 | — | $2,086,340 |
| 4.0 | 11963 | Sag Harbor | 8,390 | $50,500 | $2,399,500 |
| 4.1 | 11944 | Greenport | 5,037 | — | $951,386 |
| 5.0 | 11939 | East Marion | 1,331 | — | $1,187,307 |
| 5.8 | 11971 | Southold | 6,361 | — | $1,115,991 |
| 6.9 | 11957 | Orient | 1,121 | — | $1,524,532 |
| 7.2 | 11937 | East Hampton | 21,882 | $39,147 | $2,076,459 |
| 7.8 | 11958 | Peconic | 884 | — | $1,239,724 |
| 8.0 | 11975 | Wainscott | 450 | — | $3,473,231 |
| 8.6 | 11962 | Sagaponack | 712 | — | $6,830,656 |
| 8.6 | 11932 | Bridgehampton | 725 | $50,000 | $4,809,745 |
| 9.0 | 11976 | Water Mill | 2,952 | $65,167 | $5,118,765 |
| 9.5 | 11935 | Cutchogue | 2,863 | — | $1,249,891 |
| 11.9 | 11930 | Amagansett | 842 | $103,750 | $3,387,631 |
| 12.2 | 11968 | Southampton | 15,312 | $35,528 | $2,261,809 |
| 12.6 | 11952 | Mattituck | 5,040 | — | $1,020,018 |
| 14.2 | 11948 | Laurel | 924 | — | $1,029,275 |
| 16.9 | 11946 | Hampton Bays | 15,819 | $3,484 | $949,339 |
| 17.3 | 06475 | Old Saybrook | 10,575 | $2,767 | $698,801 |
| 18.9 | 11954 | Montauk | 4,223 | $27,500 | $2,030,557 |
| 19.0 | 06498 | Westbrook | 6,856 | — | $583,836 |
| 19.3 | 06357 | Niantic | 11,332 | $2,683 | $524,711 |
| 19.6 | 11901 | Riverhead | 33,091 | $3,189 | $655,628 |
| 19.9 | 11942 | East Quogue | 5,406 | — | $1,193,365 |
Coordinates and population from SimpleMaps US Zips (Basic). Rent and home values from Zillow Research.